- Visibility 293 Views
- Downloads 384 Downloads
- Permissions
- DOI 10.18231/j.jco.v.9.i.3.15
-
CrossMark
Unveiling the resilience of aligner materials: Comparative analysis of mechanical properties across thermoforming and saliva exposure
- Author Details:
-
Mridula Trehan
-
A Annie Maxwell *
-
Anurag Tiwari
-
Ashish Kumar
-
Anamika Jakhar
Mridula Trehan
A Annie Maxwell *
Anurag Tiwari
Ashish Kumar
Anamika Jakhar
Background: Clear aligners have become a preferred choice in orthodontics, offering aesthetic and functional advantages over traditional fixed appliances. However, their clinical performance depends on the mechanical properties of the materials, which can degrade during thermoforming and intraoral exposure.
Objective: To evaluate and compare the mechanical properties of two aligner materials—CA PRO+ and ERKODUR AL—under three conditions: pre-thermoforming, post-thermoforming, and post-saliva exposure.
Materials and Methods: An in-vitro study was conducted using 96 samples, equally divided between CA PRO+ and ERKODUR AL. Samples were tested for tensile yield stress and elastic modulus before thermoforming, after thermoforming, and following seven days of saliva exposure at 37°C. Testing was performed using an INSTRON Universal Testing Machine per ASTM D638 standards. Statistical analysis included one-way ANOVA and Tukey’s HSD for post-hoc comparisons.
Results: Both materials exhibited significant reductions in tensile yield stress and elastic modulus across the three conditions (p < 0.05). CA PRO+ showed a total tensile yield stress reduction of 15.9% (from 50.24 MPa pre-thermoforming to 42.25 MPa post-saliva exposure), while ERKODUR AL showed a similar decline of 15.9% (from 52.44 MPa to 44.05 MPa). The elastic modulus decreased by approximately 16% for both materials during the same period.
Conclusion: Thermoforming and intraoral simulation significantly degrade the mechanical properties of aligner materials, potentially impacting their clinical performance. Material selection and optimization of thermoforming processes are crucial to improving the durability and efficacy of aligners.
References
- Nakhate TS, Kangane S, Joshi YS, Bhutada PB, Nair S, Bhoir A. Evolution of orthodontic aligners: A narrative review. J Oral Res Rev. 2024;16(2):170-9.
- Eliades T, Bourauel C. Intraoral aging of orthodontic materials: The picture we miss and its clinical relevance. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2005;127(4):403–12.
- Kesling HD. The philosophy of tooth positioning appliance. Am J Orthod Oral Surg. 1945;31(6):297-304.
- Shetty SK, Wilson C, Y MK, Madhur VK. Orthodontic Treatment with Clear Aligners. Scholars J Dent Sci. 2021;8(7):230–3.
- Kudagi V, Shivakumar S, VM Ni, Nitin P. Aligners in orthodontics: A review. Int J Appl Dent Sci. 2021;7(4):187–9.
- Sheridan JJ. The Essix appliance: orthodontic appliance design and fabrication. J Clin Orthod. 1993;27(1):37-45.
- AlAhmari F, AlOtaibi F. The Effect of Fixed Orthodontic Appliances Versus Clear Aligner on Periodontal Health: A Review of the Literature. J Dent Med Sci. 2018;17:19-22.
- Jiang Q, Li J, Mei L, Du J, Levrini L, Abbate GM, Li H. Periodontal health during orthodontic treatment with clear aligners and fixed appliances: A meta-analysis. J Am Dent Assoc. 2018;149(8):712-20.
- Bayan A, Yan Y. Orthodontic treatment with clear aligners between evolution and efficiency: a literature review. Management. 2021;18:19.;
- Gao M, Yan X, Zhao R, Shan Y, Chen Y, Jian F, et al. Comparison of pain perception, anxiety, and impacts on oral health-related quality of life between patients receiving clear aligners and fixed appliances during the initial stage of orthodontic treatment. Eur J Orthod. 2020;43(3):353–9.
- Najjar HE, Alangary MA, Radwan AN, Alshehri MO, Alzahrani AH, Himdi AT, Alturkestani MA, Alsaedi MM, Alghamdi MA, Hassanein ZA. Indications, limitations, and outcomes of clear aligners in orthodontic treatment. Int J Commun Med Public Health. 202310:2604.
- Kaduskar A, Kanade A. Evolution of the efficiency and predictability of clear aligner therapy. Int J Curr Res. 2020;12(2):13074-9.
- Gold BP, Siva S, Duraisamy S, Idaayath A, Kannan R. Properties of orthodontic clear aligner materials-a review. J Evol Med Dent Sci. 2021;10(37):3288-94.
- Bucci R, D’Apuzzo F, Carotenuto G, Simeone M, Rongo R. Thickness changes in clear aligners after short-term intraoral exposure. Orthod Craniofac Res. 2019;22(4):235–41.
- Alexandropoulos A, Konstantinidis A, Papadopoulos MA, Karamolegkou M. Chemical and mechanical characterization of thermoplastic aligner materials. J Dent Res. 2015;94(3):456–63.
- Porojan L, Savin C, Topala F, Rusu LC. Surface roughness and water sorption behavior of PETG aligners. Dent Mater. 2024;40(2):249–58.
- Fang D, Liu H, Zhou X, Wang Y. Mechanical performance of orthodontic aligners under stress relaxation. J Dent Res. 2020;99(6):642–50.
- KrishnaKailash S, Patel C, Shah K, Patel A. Impact of thermoforming techniques on thickness and force generation in aligners. Clin Orthod Res. 2024;15(1):34–41.
- Olteanu A, Popa D, Scutariu M, Savin C. Compression tests for aligner deformation in orthodontic treatment. Angle Orthod. 2024;94(1):102–9.
- Matsuda A, Nakano H, Kataoka Y, Maki K. Evaluation of mechanical tests conducted before and after thermoforming of aligners. Showa Univ J Med Sci. 2023;35(3):121–30.
- Rajasekaran A, Chaudhari PK. Integrated manufacturing of direct 3D-printed clear aligners. Front Dent Med. 2023;3.
- Quinzi V, Orilisi G, Vitiello F, Notarstefano V, Marzo G, Orsini G. A spectroscopic study on orthodontic aligners: first evidence of secondary microplastic detachment after seven days of artificial saliva exposure. Sci The Total Environ. 2023;866:161356.
- Tamburrino F, D’Antò V, Bucci R, Alessandri-Bonetti G, Barone S, Razionale AV. Mechanical Properties of Thermoplastic Polymers for Aligner Manufacturing: In Vitro Study. Dent J. 2020;8(2):47.
- Dalaie K, Rafsanjan KT, Nojehdehian H, Namazi Z. Physical and chemical changes of clear aligners after thermoforming and intraoral exposure. APOS Trends Orthodontics. 2024;14:235–47.
- Šimunović L, Jurela A, Sudarević K, Bačić I, Meštrović S. Differential stability of one-layer and three-layer orthodontic aligner blends under thermocycling: implications for clinical durability. Acta Stomatologica Croatica. 2023 ;57(4):286-99.
- Fang D, Zhang N, Chen H, Bai Y. Dynamic stress relaxation of orthodontic thermoplastic materials in a simulated oral environment. Dennt Mat J. 2013;32(6):946–51.
- Staderini E, Chiusolo G, Guglielmi F, Papi M, Perini G, Tepedino M, et al. Effects of Thermoforming on the Mechanical, Optical, Chemical, and Morphological Properties of PET-G: In Vitro Study. Polymers. 2024;16(2):203. 392 Trehan et al. / Journal of Contemporary Orthodontics 2025;9(3):388–392
- Matsuda A, Nakano H, Kataoka Y, Maki K. Evaluation of mechanical tests conducted before and after thermoforming of aligners. Showa Univ J Med Sci. 2023;35(3):121–30.
- Ihssen BA, Willmann JH, Nimer A, Drescher D. Effect of in vitro aging by water immersion and thermocycling on the mechanical properties of PETG aligner material. J Orofac Orthopedics/Fortschritte der Kieferorthopadie. 2019;80(6):292-
- Lira LF, Vargas EO, da Silva EM, Dória JN, Elzubair A, de Morais LS. et al. Effect of oral exposure on chemical, physical, mechanical, and morphologic properties of clear orthodontic aligners. Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop. 2023;164(2):e51-63
- Bradley TG, Berzins DW, Eliades G, Eliades T. Structure and properties of aligners after intraoral aging. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2015;147(5):659–67.
- Sayahpour S, Foroutan S, Mehrabi MA. Multi-layer aligners and resistance to mechanical aging. Clin Oral Investig. 2024;28(1):217–
- Olteanu ND, Szuhanek C, Rosu SN, Chitariu DF, Seghedin N, Panaite T, Casalean A, Zetu IN. An Assessment of the Mechanical Deformation Behavior of Three Different Clear Aligner Materials: A Digital Image Correlation Analysis. Appl Sci. 2024;14(17):7496.
- Porojan L, et al. Saliva exposure and surface changes in orthodontic aligners. Dent Mater. 2024;40(2):249–58.
- Bucci R, Rongo R, Levatè C, Michelotti A, Barone S, Razionale AV, D’Antò V. Thickness of orthodontic clear aligners after thermoforming and after 10 days of intraoral exposure: a prospective clinical study. Progress in orthodontics. 2019;20(1):1-
- Staderini E, Lombardo L, Ortu E. Surface and optical changes in PET-G aligners post-thermoforming. Eur J Orthod. 2024;46(1):e12–8.
- Tamburrino R. Thermal processing effects on orthodontic aligners. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. 2020;104:103658.
- Kwon TY, et al. Effects of thermoforming on material properties of orthodontic aligners. J Appl Oral Sci. 2018;26:e20170145.
- Siotou K, Chountalas T, Katsavrias A, Siotos C, Mpalias K, Semitekolos D, Charitidis C, Tsolakis AI. The mechanical properties of orthodontic aligners of clear aligner after intraoral use in different time periods. Orthod Craniofac Res. 2025;28(2):253-60.
- Srinivasan B, Padmanabhan S, Srinivasan S. Comparative evaluation of physical and mechanical properties of clear aligners– a systematic review. Evid Based Dent. 2024;25(1):53.